Tinder Trap: NJ Woman Indicted in Shocking Murder-for-Hire Plot Against Ex-Cop

Imagine a breakup so acrimonious, so utterly venomous, that one party allegedly decides murder is the only way out. Well, that's precisely the chilling scenario unfolding in federal court for a New Jersey woman, Jaclyn D. Diiorio. She's now staring down federal murder-for-hire charges, accused of trying to have her former boyfriend, a Philadelphia police officer, killed, and here's the twist: it allegedly all began with a Tinder match.

It's a story that truly makes you pause, detailing how a relationship between Diiorio, a hairdresser from Runnemede, and Matthew O'Hanlon, a Philadelphia police officer, soured to an unimaginable degree after their split on March 6, 2025. But this wasn't just any bitter parting. Oh no, the plot thickened, or rather, descended into something far more sinister, allegedly involving a seemingly innocuous Tinder connection.

According to federal prosecutors, Diiorio didn't just brood; she allegedly got busy, utilizing her cell phone between March 30 and April 5, 2025, to orchestrate O'Hanlon's demise. The unwitting, or perhaps just unlucky, instrument of this alleged scheme? A confidential informant, who also happened to be a Tinder match. Can you imagine matching with someone, only to find yourself embroiled in a murder-for-hire plot?

The initial arrangements, court documents suggest, were as mundane as they were chilling. Meetings supposedly took place at a Wawa convenience store, followed by a payment of what was likely a down payment in a Gloucester Township Dollar General parking lot. Eventually, Diiorio found herself arrested in her Honda Civic in a Glendora parking lot, the alleged plot unraveling around her.

Fast forward to September 9, 2026, and the hammer dropped. The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania unsealed the indictment, bringing federal murder-for-hire charges against Diiorio. This wasn't her first brush with the law regarding this incident, mind you. Camden County prosecutors had already slapped her with attempted murder and conspiracy charges back in April 2025. Now, U.S. Attorney David Metcalf and his team are pursuing justice on a national level, a clear signal of the gravity of these accusations.

Diiorio, who is expected to plead not guilty to these federal charges, now faces a formidable legal battle in the U.S. District Court in Philadelphia. It’s a stark reminder of how quickly personal grievances can allegedly spiral into criminal acts of the most serious nature. The story of Jaclyn D. Diiorio and the alleged Tinder-fueled murder plot against her ex-boyfriend is a truly unsettling one, and we'll undoubtedly be following the developments as they unfold in court.