SNL's Sarah Sherman Unleashes 'The Gutter Press' on Hot Ones

You know those interviews that just pop off? The ones where you’re watching and thinking, 'Okay, something wild is definitely about to happen here'? Well, when SNL's very own Sarah Sherman and Chloe Fineman sat down for a fiery session of 'Hot Ones' – yes, the show with increasingly spicy wings – things were destined to get a little… chaotic. And truly, they delivered, offering up a masterclass in hilarious, cringe-inducing mischief that only these two could orchestrate.

Amidst the escalating heat of the wings, the conversation naturally veered into a delightful realm of celebrity hijinks. But instead of just recounting past pranks, Sarah Sherman, with that signature twinkle in her eye, decided it was high time for some live, unscripted comedy. The target? Her unsuspecting SNL co-star, Marcello Hernandez. Armed with a burner phone and a truly outrageous alter ego, Sherman was ready to unleash a wave of glorious, awkward absurdity.

She morphed into a tenacious 'journalist' from the utterly fictitious 'The Gutter Press' – a name that already tells you everything you need to know about its journalistic integrity, or lack thereof. Marcello, bless his heart, answered the call, completely unaware he was about to become fodder for one of the most wonderfully bizarre interviews of his life. Sherman, with a straight face, began lobbing utterly ludicrous questions at him. Think deep dives into his alleged personal hygiene habits, wildly speculative relationship rumors, and vague accusations about his past, all delivered with an air of absolute conviction. The kicker? She kept insisting she had 'sources.' Can you even imagine?

The beauty of this particular prank was watching Marcello’s genuine bewilderment. He wasn't just confused; he was genuinely trying to make sense of this bizarre interrogation, stammering out explanations and denials against the backdrop of Sarah’s relentless, deadpan questioning. You could almost feel his brain cells short-circuiting trying to compute why this 'journalist' was so invested in the purported cleanliness of his teeth or the speculative drama of his dating life. It was a masterclass in awkward, an escalating symphony of discomfort that had Chloe Fineman – and surely everyone watching – absolutely roaring with laughter.

Having thoroughly discombobulated Marcello, the stage was set for round two. This time, the comedic heavy-hitter David Spade was in the crosshairs. Now, pranking a seasoned comedian like David Spade is a whole different ballgame. He’s been in the trenches; he knows the smell of a setup. But Sarah, ever the optimist, was ready for the challenge.

Again, the 'Gutter Press' persona emerged, ready to pounce. But Spade, with his trademark dry wit and keen observational skills, wasn't so easily fooled. Almost immediately, he seemed to sense something was amiss. The questions, though still absurdly specific, landed differently. Where Marcello had tried to reason, Spade began to poke holes, his responses laced with suspicion and an almost immediate recognition that he was likely being played. He wasn't giving up any personal hygiene secrets today, no sir. It wasn’t long before he called out the charade, confirming what we all knew: David Spade is just too sharp to fall for the Gutter Press.

What these two prank calls really showcased was Sarah Sherman’s distinctive comedic genius. It's not just about the bizarre questions; it's her unwavering commitment to the bit, her ability to maintain a perfectly straight face while uttering the most outlandish statements. Her humor thrives on that delicious tension between the absurd and the uncomfortable, making us simultaneously cringe and convulse with laughter. She embodies a kind of comedic fearlessness that’s truly magnetic.

And let’s not forget Chloe Fineman, who was right there beside her, a wonderful audience surrogate, her infectious laughter amplifying the sheer joy of the moment. Seeing these SNL stars, known for their sketch comedy, bring that same chaotic energy to a real-world (well, real-interview) scenario was an absolute treat. It was a stark reminder that sometimes, the best comedy isn't scripted; it’s the wonderfully awkward, completely unhinged moments that pop up when you least expect them. A true 'Hot Ones' classic, wouldn't you say?