Sibling Showdown: Brooks Nader's Carlos Alcaraz 'Joke' Ignites Fiery Family Feud with Sister Grace

Model Brooks Nader recently found herself in the hot seat, revealing a month-long silent treatment from her sister, Grace Nader, all because of a playful (or perhaps not-so-playful) claim about tennis sensation Carlos Alcaraz. The drama unfolded after Brooks, during a lie detector test for a Barstool Sports podcast, lightheartedly stated she was “dating” Alcaraz.

Little did she know, this seemingly innocent remark would plunge her into an unexpected sibling spat, leading to Grace blocking her on Instagram.

The confession came during an episode of the “Sofia with an F” podcast, where Brooks, known for her candidness, made the bombshell admission. “I did not speak to my sister for a month,” Brooks confessed, detailing the frosty reception.

“She blocked me on everything. She blocked me on Instagram. She blocked me on Venmo.” The intensity of Grace’s reaction highlights the depth of her fandom for Alcaraz and perhaps a sisterly protectiveness, given the public scrutiny that comes with celebrity relationships.

Brooks recounted the immediate fallout.

“Immediately after I said it, I got a text message from her being like, ‘What the f–k?’ And I knew exactly what she was talking about,” she explained. Grace, a self-proclaimed huge fan of Alcaraz, took the “dating” claim much more seriously than Brooks intended. “She was protecting him,” Brooks added, acknowledging Grace’s fierce loyalty to the Spanish tennis star.

It seems Grace wasn’t just upset about a potential rival; she was concerned about the implications for Alcaraz himself.

In an attempt to mend fences, Brooks quickly clarified the situation on her Instagram Stories, revealing that the entire Alcaraz claim was a joke and she had never actually met the athlete.

This public retraction finally led to Grace unblocking her, signaling a tentative truce. However, the saga didn't end there. Brooks, seemingly unable to resist, then posted a video implying Alcaraz had DM’d her, further stoking the flames of the “joke.”

Despite the unblocking, the sisterly tension lingered.

Brooks admitted that Grace was still giving her “the cold shoulder” in the immediate aftermath. This isn't just about a celebrity crush; it’s a relatable tale of sibling dynamics, where playful banter can sometimes cross a line, especially when a beloved public figure is involved. For two sisters who are typically very close, this Alcaraz ‘scandal’ proved to be an unusual test of their bond, showcasing how even the most innocuous comments can snowball into significant family drama.