Heartbreaking Animal Cruelty Case Uncovered in Brant, Dozens Rescued

It's truly heartbreaking to report on stories like this, but a recent animal cruelty investigation in Brant, New York, has uncovered a profoundly disturbing situation, one that’s left many reeling. What started as a simple complaint back in July of 2023 quickly escalated into a full-blown rescue operation, revealing a grim scene of neglect and suffering on a property located at 1040 Brant North Collins Road.

Investigators, led by the diligent efforts of the SPCA of Erie County, were met with a truly shocking sight. Amidst the property, they found not just neglected living animals, but also the remains of others – specifically, several deceased goats and, chillingly, various animal bones, including what was identified as a horse skull. It paints a picture of long-term suffering, you know?

But the horror didn't stop there. What's more, dozens of animals were discovered in appalling conditions, clearly suffering from severe neglect. Imagine seeing animals that were painfully emaciated, some struggling with terribly overgrown hooves, and others plagued by serious skin conditions. It's a testament to their resilience that they were still clinging to life. Ultimately, authorities made the decision to seize a significant number of these poor creatures: eighteen goats, ten dogs, a mini horse, a pony, a donkey, and even a cat, totaling 31 animals now under the care of the SPCA.

As a result of this comprehensive investigation, two individuals have been formally charged. Amanda Fetterly, 38, is facing a staggering 38 counts of animal cruelty. Her partner, William Fetterly, 40, has also been charged with ten counts of animal cruelty. These aren't just minor infractions; these are serious accusations reflecting severe neglect and mistreatment.

And honestly, the situation might be even larger than initially thought. Investigators have also noted the presence of additional animals on the property, which the SPCA is now closely monitoring. The dedicated team at the SPCA of Erie County has truly stepped up, working tirelessly to ensure these rescued animals receive the urgent care and attention they so desperately need.

Looking ahead, the legal process is underway. Both Amanda and William Fetterly are scheduled to appear in the Brant Town Court on October 3, 2023, to answer to these charges. It's a stark reminder that animal welfare is a serious concern, and hopefully, justice will be served for these vulnerable creatures.