A Glimpse Into Luxury: The Toms River Area's Most Expensive Home Sales

Ever wondered what kind of stunning properties are selling for top dollar in our beautiful corner of New Jersey? Well, let's pull back the curtain on the real estate market in the Toms River area for a moment. The week of March 2nd through March 8th, 2026, was quite interesting, with some truly magnificent homes finding new owners across several towns. It's always fascinating to see where the demand lies, isn't it?

From serene waterfront havens to spacious, comfortable estates, these ten homes really caught our eye, reflecting the vibrant and dynamic nature of the local housing scene. Let's take a little tour, shall we, of the priciest transactions that recently closed, offering a peek into what buyers are looking for in this sought-after region.

Leading the pack, with an impressive sale price, is a breathtaking residence at 38 South Drive in Island Heights. This absolute gem, a four-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath home spanning a generous 3,420 square feet, fetched a cool $1,750,000. It’s a true waterfront property, as you might imagine, offering those coveted views and direct access that makes Island Heights so special.

Next up, we journey to 605 Pointview Road in Toms River itself. This lovely four-bedroom, three-bath home, with 2,828 square feet of living space, commanded a strong $1,475,000. Another exquisite waterfront offering, it truly highlights the premium placed on properties that embrace the area's natural beauty.

Making a significant splash at $1,050,000, we find a charming three-bedroom, two-bath abode at 306 Fielder Avenue in Berkeley. While a bit more modest in size at 1,748 square feet, its undeniable waterfront appeal clearly played a huge role in its valuation. Sometimes, it's all about that prime location!

Just shy of the million-dollar mark, a delightful home at 207 East River Avenue in Lacey sold for $975,000. This three-bedroom, two-bath property, covering 1,720 square feet, is yet another testament to the enduring allure of waterfront living in our area. Buyers are definitely prioritizing those scenic views and direct water access.

Returning to the picturesque streets of Island Heights, a wonderful three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath house at 27 Kettle Creek Road found a new owner for $950,000. This home, with a comfortable 2,420 square feet, offers a different kind of charm, showcasing that desirability isn't solely tied to waterfront property in this beautiful town.

Shifting gears slightly, an expansive three-bedroom, three-bath residence at 640 W Village Drive in Manchester changed hands for $830,000. Boasting a very spacious 3,252 square feet, this property stands out, particularly as it's within an age-restricted community, suggesting a strong market for luxury senior living options.

Down in Lacey, we see another solid sale at 172 Ocean Avenue. This three-bedroom, two-bath home, with 1,592 square feet, was purchased for $750,000. It’s a perfect example of how demand extends across various property types and locations within our wider region.

Back in Toms River, a generous four-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath house at 376 Old Dover Road sold for $730,000. Spanning 2,348 square feet, this home offers plenty of room and comfort, appealing to those looking for a substantial family residence without the direct waterfront price tag.

In Brick, a lovely three-bedroom, two-bath home at 54 Beacon Boulevard secured a price of $720,000. With 1,768 square feet, it's a very respectable sale, showcasing the continued appeal of Brick Township's residential offerings.

And finally, rounding out our top ten, another Brick Township property at 46 Princeton Avenue, a three-bedroom, two-bath house of 1,440 square feet, sold for $699,000. It demonstrates that even below the three-quarter-million-dollar mark, high-quality, well-located homes are attracting strong interest and competitive pricing.

So there you have it – a fascinating snapshot of the high-end residential real estate market in the greater Toms River area during that first week of March. It's clear that whether it's the allure of the water, spacious layouts, or sought-after communities, quality homes continue to draw significant investment. It's truly a dynamic market, full of opportunities and, let's be honest, some truly gorgeous homes!