The Uncanny Prediction: A Fan Called James Gunn's Superman & Lois Casting Nearly 5 Years Ago!
Share- Nishadil
- August 19, 2025
- 0 Comments
- 3 minutes read
- 4 Views

In the vast, passionate world of comic book fandom, whispers and theories abound, often fading into the digital ether. But occasionally, a prediction emerges that is so uncannily accurate, it defies belief. Such is the case with a remarkable DC fan whose foresight into the casting of James Gunn’s new ‘Superman’ film has left the internet utterly flabbergasted.
Nearly five years ago – precisely 1,721 days before the official announcement, to be exact – a Reddit user operating under the moniker u/TheBatFlash (now known as u/TheFlashBat) penned a post on the r/DC_Cinematic subreddit that can only be described as prophetic.
On February 26, 2021, amidst countless other speculative threads, they confidently put forth their picks for the iconic roles of Clark Kent/Superman and Lois Lane: David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan, respectively.
What makes this prediction truly astonishing is not just the accuracy, but the meticulous reasoning behind it.
For Corenswet as the Man of Steel, the fan cited his "classic Superman looks," noting his uncanny resemblance to the beloved hero’s traditional portrayal. For Lois Lane, they championed Rachel Brosnahan, highlighting her established prowess as a "great actress" and a "fast talker," qualities essential for the sharp-witted Daily Planet reporter.
The user also pointed to the potential for "good chemistry," a vital element for the beloved duo.
Fast forward to June 2023, and the DC Universe was set ablaze with the highly anticipated casting announcement for James Gunn’s Superman (then titled Superman: Legacy). The news confirmed none other than David Corenswet as the new Kal-El and Rachel Brosnahan as the intrepid Lois Lane.
The collective gasp across the internet was almost audible as fans realized the astonishing congruence with the nearly half-decade-old Reddit post.
The original poster, now a verified seer in the eyes of the DC community, couldn't contain their excitement and disbelief. Taking to Twitter, u/TheFlashBat expressed their joyous shock, exclaiming, "I CALLED IT!" The internet, in turn, erupted with a mix of awe and playful reverence, acknowledging that some mere mortals, indeed, possess an almost supernatural gift for foresight.
This remarkable incident serves as a heartwarming reminder of the deep engagement and keen insight within fan communities.
While Hollywood keeps its secrets close, sometimes, just sometimes, a true fan’s intuition can cut through the noise and reveal a glimpse of the future. It’s a testament to the passionate dedication of fandom, proving that sometimes, the best predictions come not from industry insiders, but from those who simply love the heroes they follow.
.Disclaimer: This article was generated in part using artificial intelligence and may contain errors or omissions. The content is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. We makes no representations or warranties regarding its accuracy, completeness, or reliability. Readers are advised to verify the information independently before relying on