Unveiling the Elite: Newark Area's Top 10 Luxury Home Sales Last Week

Well, what a week it was for high-end real estate in and around Newark, New Jersey! From December 15th to the 21st, 2025, the local market truly outdid itself, showcasing a fascinating array of properties that commanded some serious prices. It really gives you a glimpse into where the top-tier demand is right now, doesn't it?

We’re talking about homes that aren’t just houses; they’re statements, havens, and sometimes, even a piece of history. This particular week saw ten incredible transactions, each one telling its own story of luxury, desirability, and often, incredible craftsmanship. So, let’s peel back the layers and explore these standout sales, shall we?

Leading the pack, with an eye-watering sale price of $4.85 million, was an absolutely stunning estate located at 123 Whisperwood Drive in Short Hills. This isn't just a home; it’s a sprawling modern masterpiece, boasting seven bedrooms, six full baths, and all the bells and whistles you could possibly dream of. Think infinity pool, a state-of-the-art home theater, and meticulously landscaped grounds that offer unparalleled privacy. It’s the kind of place that makes you wonder who gets to call it home – a true testament to the ultra-luxury segment thriving in our area.

Just a hair under, at $3.7 million, we saw a magnificent Victorian beauty change hands at 789 Grandview Avenue in Montclair. This isn't your average old house, mind you; it’s been lovingly restored, blending its original architectural grandeur – those intricate details, the soaring ceilings – with every conceivable modern amenity. Imagine over 6,000 square feet of living space, a gourmet kitchen that chefs would swoon over, and a generous lot perfect for entertaining. It’s Montclair at its very best, showcasing that timeless appeal.

Next up, a charming, yet undeniably grand, colonial-style residence at 456 Maplewood Lane in South Orange fetched a cool $2.9 million. This property really stood out for its classic elegance and expansive interiors. With five bedrooms and a particularly generous backyard, it felt like the perfect blend of suburban tranquility and sophisticated living. Families, especially those looking for space and a vibrant community, often gravitate towards homes like this one.

Over in Livingston, a rather impressive contemporary home at 101 Serenity Way closed for $2.55 million. This place was all about sleek lines and open spaces, with floor-to-ceiling windows that just flood the rooms with natural light. It also featured a fantastic indoor-outdoor flow, ideal for those who love to entertain or simply enjoy the feeling of nature close by. A definite draw for anyone seeking modern comfort and privacy.

Then we have 22 Elmwood Drive in Millburn, a truly elegant Tudor that sold for $2.3 million. This home exuded a kind of old-world charm, yet it was clear from the listing that no expense was spared in updating its interiors. Think rich wood details, beautiful stone fireplaces, and a chef's kitchen that somehow manages to feel both classic and utterly contemporary. It's a testament to the enduring appeal of quality craftsmanship.

Maplewood also made an appearance on our list with a delightful Craftsman-style home at 33 Oak Street, securing $1.98 million. What makes homes like this so special is their character – the built-ins, the thoughtful design, and often, the beautifully mature gardens. This particular one had been meticulously renovated, retaining its original charm while offering all the modern comforts. It’s easy to see why it commanded such a price.

Heading a bit further west, a spacious executive home in Caldwell, specifically at 77 Beacon Hill Road, sold for $1.75 million. This property really delivered on amenities, featuring a dedicated home office, a fully equipped gym, and even a media room. It’s the kind of house that caters to a modern family’s every need, especially for those who appreciate both space and convenience.

Another Montclair gem, though this time in Upper Montclair, at 55 Stonegate Lane, closed at $1.65 million. This stately brick colonial offered a fantastic blend of historic appeal and comfortable living. Its location, often a key factor, likely played a significant role here, providing easy access to local amenities and excellent schools. A classic choice for discerning buyers, truly.

In West Orange, a custom-built residence at 99 Summit View Terrace achieved a sale price of $1.52 million. The name itself, Summit View, hints at one of its major draws: incredible panoramic views of the surrounding landscape, perhaps even the NYC skyline on a clear day. Custom homes like these are often about unique features and a design tailored to the owner's specific vision, and this one certainly didn't disappoint.

And finally, rounding out our top ten, we venture into Newark itself, specifically the beautiful Forest Hill Historic District. A beautifully restored Victorian at 88 Elm Place sold for $1.4 million. This is a truly significant sale, demonstrating the strong appeal of Newark's historic neighborhoods. Buyers are clearly recognizing the value and unique character these grand old homes offer, especially when they've been brought back to life with such care and attention to detail. It's wonderful to see!

So there you have it – a whirlwind tour of the Newark area's most expensive home sales from that remarkable week. It’s clear that the luxury market here is robust and diverse, attracting buyers who are looking for everything from sleek, modern estates to beautifully preserved historic gems. Each of these sales underscores a dynamic market where quality, location, and unique features continue to drive significant value. It really makes you wonder what next week will bring, doesn't it?