The Mütter Museum's Ethical Evolution: Redefining Stewardship of Human Remains

The Mütter Museum in Philadelphia, a venerated institution long celebrated for its extraordinary collection of anatomical specimens, medical anomalies, and historical instruments, is embarking on a profound and necessary transformation. In a move that reflects a global reckoning within the museum community, the Mütter Museum is overhauling its policies concerning the acquisition, display, and stewardship of human remains, aiming to align itself with modern ethical standards and prioritize respect for the deceased and their communities.

For generations, the Mütter Museum, part of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia, has captivated visitors with its unique and often unsettling displays, from the skeletal remains of conjoined twins Chang and Eng Bunker to the remarkable Hyrtl Skull Collection.

However, the very nature of these collections, many acquired in an era when ethical considerations were vastly different or non-existent, has prompted a critical self-assessment. The new policies are a direct response to this historical context, acknowledging that many remains were obtained without consent, often from marginalized individuals or through questionable means, like grave robbery or the exploitation of the impoverished.

At the heart of this ethical overhaul is a commitment to responsible stewardship.

The museum will no longer acquire human remains unless under exceptional circumstances and with explicit, documented consent. This forward-looking approach contrasts sharply with past practices, which saw many remains become part of the collection without the individual's or their family's permission.

Furthermore, the museum has initiated a comprehensive review of its entire collection of approximately 20,000 human remains, a monumental task that seeks to identify origins, research provenience, and establish the most respectful path forward for each item.

One of the most significant changes already implemented involves the Hyrtl Skull Collection, a collection of 139 human skulls amassed in the 19th century by Austrian anatomist Joseph Hyrtl.

Many of these skulls were obtained from executions or dissection rooms, again, without consent. Previously a prominent public display, these skulls have now been moved off exhibit and into secure, private storage. They will remain accessible for crucial scientific research and educational purposes, but only by appointment, symbolizing a shift from public spectacle to respectful academic engagement.

The museum emphasizes that the goal is not to "hide" history, but to curate it ethically, with digital representations and advanced photography now serving as public access points for these particular collections.

Other iconic exhibits are also under review. The "Soap Lady," a remarkably preserved body naturally saponified into a soap-like substance, remains on display for now, but its long-term future is part of the ongoing ethical re-evaluation.

Similarly, the skeletons and plaster cast of the connected livers of Chang and Eng Bunker, the famous conjoined twins, are being carefully considered. The museum's new framework prioritizes the wishes of descendants and communities, making repatriation a central tenet of its updated policies where appropriate and feasible.

This bold step by the Mütter Museum places it at the forefront of a global movement.

Museums worldwide are grappling with similar questions regarding their collections, particularly those involving human remains and objects acquired during colonial periods or through exploitative practices. The Mütter aims to be a leader in this evolving landscape, demonstrating that an institution can honor its past and its unique identity while embracing a future built on transparency, respect, and ethical accountability.

The public reaction has been varied.

While many laud the museum's commitment to ethical practices and historical redress, some long-time visitors and enthusiasts express a sense of loss for the traditional, more sensationalized displays. However, the museum asserts that its mission remains rooted in education and the advancement of medical history, albeit through a more sensitive and humane lens.

By re-evaluating its displays and acquisition methods, the Mütter Museum is not diminishing its legacy but enriching it, ensuring that its powerful narratives are told with dignity and integrity for generations to come.

.