Steelers' Punter Battle: Waitman vs. Johnston for Crucial Roster Spot

The air at Pittsburgh Steelers training camp is thick with anticipation, not just for offensive fireworks or defensive dominance, but for a high-stakes battle unfolding in one of the NFL's most underrated positions: punter. The team faces a pivotal decision as they weigh the merits of former Steeler Corliss Waitman against seasoned veteran Cameron Johnston, a choice that could significantly impact special teams performance for the upcoming season.

For many fans, Corliss Waitman is a familiar face, having stepped in for a crucial two-game stretch with the Steelers during the 2021 season when Pressley Harvin III was sidelined.

His brief but impactful tenure left an impression, and since then, Waitman has continued to hone his craft, making stops with the Denver Broncos and New England Patriots. He brings a raw power and an eagerness to reclaim a permanent spot, showcased by his commendable performance in the Steelers' initial preseason outing where he averaged an impressive 49.3 yards on four punts.

Waitman's journey is one of resilience, fighting for every opportunity to prove his worth on an NFL roster.

Challenging Waitman for the role is Cameron Johnston, a veteran presence who joined the Steelers in March. Johnston boasts a more extensive NFL resume, known for his consistent leg and experience under pressure.

His 2023 season saw him average a robust 47.7 yards per punt, a testament to his reliability and ability to flip field position. With a solid contract in hand, Johnston represents a safer, proven option, a player who has consistently performed at a high level. Interestingly, Johnston did not get a chance to punt in the team's first preseason game, leaving fans and coaches eager to see him in action as the competition heats up.

The punter position, often overlooked, is absolutely vital to a team's success.

A strong punter can pin opponents deep, preventing scoring drives and giving the defense a significant advantage. Conversely, a poor punter can repeatedly put the defense in difficult situations. The Steelers, a franchise built on gritty, fundamental football, understand this implicitly. Special teams coordinator Danny Smith will undoubtedly be scrutinizing every hang time, every directional punt, and every nuance of both players' techniques.

The decision facing the Steelers coaching staff is not an easy one.

Waitman offers an exciting upside and a strong initial showing, but he faces a financial disadvantage compared to Johnston's existing contract. Johnston, on the other hand, provides a track record of consistent, high-level play. This battle isn't just about who can kick the ball the farthest; it's about who can best execute under pressure, who can consistently deliver pinpoint punts, and who embodies the reliability that special teams demands.

As training camp progresses, all eyes will be on Waitman and Johnston as they vie for the chance to be the Steelers' primary punter for the new season. The outcome will be a crucial piece in Pittsburgh's quest for another successful year.