Saugeen Shores Grapples with Skyrocketing Policing Costs as OPP Contract Nears Expiry

Saugeen Shores is bracing for a significant financial challenge as the cost of policing in the vibrant municipality is set to skyrocket. With the current Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) contract nearing its expiration at the close of 2024, residents and council members are grappling with projections that indicate a substantial 14.9 percent increase in policing expenses for next year, potentially pushing the annual bill to a staggering $6.5 million.

Currently, Saugeen Shores allocates approximately $5.7 million for policing services in 2024.

This impending surge in costs has ignited a fervent debate within the council chambers regarding the necessity of a comprehensive review of the municipality's law enforcement options. Many are questioning whether the current arrangement with the OPP continues to offer the most fiscally responsible and effective solution for the growing community.

Deputy Mayor Matthew Coughlin has been a vocal proponent for a thorough re-evaluation, asserting that council has a "moral obligation" to explore all avenues before committing to a new contract.

He highlights the dramatic rise from the $3.8 million cost incurred during the last major review in 2017, underscoring the urgency of understanding the drivers behind these escalating figures and seeking optimal value for taxpayer money.

However, the path forward is not without contention. Mayor Luke Charbonneau acknowledges the diligent work of the previous 2017 review, which concluded that the OPP offered the most cost-effective policing solution at the time.

He emphasizes the importance of maintaining the high level of service the community currently enjoys, suggesting a cautious approach to any potentially disruptive changes.

Councillor Rachel Stack, while expressing satisfaction with the OPP's service, has voiced concerns about the long-term sustainability of the escalating costs.

She argues that even if the OPP remains the preferred option, a fresh review is crucial to ensure that the current contract terms are as efficient and cost-effective as possible, and to thoroughly understand the implications of continued growth in policing expenditures.

The core of the debate lies in balancing public safety with fiscal responsibility.

As the contract deadline looms, Saugeen Shores faces a critical decision that will undoubtedly have a direct impact on property taxes and the financial well-being of its residents. Without a clear consensus on whether to initiate a new, in-depth review, the municipality finds itself at a crossroads, needing to navigate complex financial projections and community expectations to secure the best possible policing solution for its future.