Most States Have Tax Codes That Are Rigged To Benefit The Wealthy: Report

LOADING ERROR LOADING A sweeping new analysis of taxes across the country reveals that in four out of every five states, the top 1% are paying a lower tax rate than their middle class and low income neighbors. Instead of taxing wealthy residents an equal share, the vast majority of states are filling their budget gaps with taxes that disproportionately burden lower income families, according to a report by the nonpartisan Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, titled “Who Pays?” Advertisement “When we look at how states are taxing their residents, it’s clear they’re falling very far short of what most people consider to be a fair tax code,” said Carl Davis, ITEP’s research director.

In the top 10 states with the most regressive systems — Florida, Washington, Tennessee, Pennsylvania, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Illinois, Arkansas and Louisiana — the middle 60% of families pay an average of twice as much of their income in taxes as the top 1%, and the poorest 20% of residents pay an average of three times as much as the very wealthiest.

Thirty four states tax low income households at a higher rate than every other group. “The core problem is not that complicated,” Davis said. “The problem is that state and local governments are raising most of their tax revenue from regressive taxes on what people buy, or the homes that they own or rent, and those expenses swallow up a larger share of income for low and middle income people.” The report is the most comprehensive picture available of the overall share of income that families pay in state and local taxes across all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

It examined not only income taxes but also taxes on goods, services, sales, fuel, property — even obscure levies such as South Dakota’s snowmobile excise tax — along with savings through rebates, exemptions and deductions. Advertisement “Being regressive is not accidental. It’s policy changes over time.” Sadaf Knight, CEO of the nonpartisan Florida Policy Institute States are growing more dependent on these regressive taxes because most have weakened or eliminated their personal income taxes.

In 44 states, the tax code actually worsens income inequality because the top 1% are left with a much larger share of their income after taxes than everyone else. “Being regressive is not accidental. It’s policy changes over time,” said Sadaf Knight, CEO of the nonpartisan Florida Policy Institute.

Florida has the most regressive tax structures in the country because the legislature has repeatedly gutted corporate income taxes and hiked sales taxes to compensate, she said. Advertisement In 2022, a court in Arizona killed a voter approved tax on the state’s top 1% of income earners that would have raised almost $1 billion annually to fund education.

If the tax had remained on the books, Arizona would have joined the middle of the pack. Instead, it ranks 13th in overall inequality. Other states permit taxpayers to deduct their federal income and capital gains taxes. Because the federal income tax is progressive and wealthy taxpayers are more likely to owe taxes on capital gains from their investments, these tax breaks disproportionately benefit the ultra rich — and pervert a progressive income tax into a regressive one.

Though no state has a genuinely progressive tax structure, some are more equitable. The least regressive are Minnesota, Vermont, New York, New Jersey, California, Maine, Massachusetts, New Mexico, Oregon and the District of Columbia. In those nine states and D.C., the top 1% paid a similar or slightly higher marginal tax rate than middle income or low income families.

They also have either a graduated income tax, limits on deductions for wealthy taxpayers, a state inheritance or estate tax or a mix of those. All 10 offer special tax refunds for low and middle income families. Massachusetts leapt in the equality rankings after voters approved the Fair Share Amendment in 2022 and imposed a 4% tax on income over $1 million.

The state has projected that it will raise $1.5 billion by June 2024. Advertisement “It is just really gratifying to see the results,” said Phineas Baxandall, the interim president at the Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center. “The tax money being generated from the millionaire’s tax is the reason why free school meals haven’t gone away — the reason why we’re not having to do cutbacks on early education.” Support HuffPost The Stakes Have Never Been Higher At HuffPost, we believe that everyone needs high quality journalism, but we understand that not everyone can afford to pay for expensive news subscriptions.

That is why we are committed to providing deeply reported, carefully fact checked news that is freely accessible to everyone. Our News, Politics and Culture teams invest time and care working on hard hitting investigations and researched analyses, along with quick but robust daily takes. Our Life, Health and Shopping desks provide you with well researched, expert vetted information you need to live your best life, while HuffPost Personal, Voices and Opinion center real stories from real people.

Help keep news free for everyone by giving us as little as $1. Your contribution will go a long way. At HuffPost, we believe that everyone needs high quality journalism, but we understand that not everyone can afford to pay for expensive news subscriptions. That is why we are committed to providing deeply reported, carefully fact checked news that is freely accessible to everyone.

Help keep news free for everyone by giving us as little as $1. Your contribution will go a long way. As the 2024 presidential race heats up, the very foundations of our democracy are at stake. A vibrant democracy is impossible without well informed citizens. This is why HuffPost's journalism is free for everyone, not just those who can afford expensive paywalls.

We cannot do this without your help. Support our newsroom by contributing as little as $1 a month. As the 2024 presidential race heats up, the very foundations of our democracy are at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a vibrant democracy is impossible without well informed citizens. This is why we keep our journalism free for everyone, even as most other newsrooms have retreated behind expensive paywalls.

Our newsroom continues to bring you hard hitting investigations, well researched analysis and timely takes on one of the most consequential elections in recent history. Reporting on the current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly — and we need your help. Support our newsroom by contributing as little as $1 a month.

Support HuffPost Related wealth inequality state and local taxes The Ultrawealthy Have Made $8.5 Trillion — And None Of It’s Been Taxed: Report New York Considers Reparations For Descendants Of Enslaved People Kim Kardashian Criticized For Extravagant 'Winter Wonderland' At LA Mansion LEAVE A COMMENT Molly Redden Senior Politics Reporter, HuffPost Suggest a correction Do you have info to share with HuffPost reporters? Here’s how.

Go to Homepage Popular in the Community FROM OUR PARTNER.