A Glimpse into Grandeur: Toms River Area's Top 10 Luxury Home Sales

Toms River and its enchanting surrounding communities have always held a special allure, particularly for those dreaming of coastal elegance and a touch of upscale living. It’s a place where the Atlantic breeze meets charming neighborhoods, and the real estate market, well, it certainly reflects that desirability. You know, sometimes you just have to wonder what kind of stories these magnificent homes could tell, and the latest sales figures always offer a fascinating peek behind the curtain.

This past week, specifically between December 1st and 7th, 2025, saw a flurry of activity in the higher echelons of the market. We’ve rounded up the ten most expensive homes that changed hands in the Toms River area, giving us a unique snapshot of what discerning buyers are truly looking for. So, let’s dive in, shall we, and explore these architectural beauties and the lifestyles they promise!

Kicking off our list at a staggering $3,850,000 was a breathtaking estate at 123 Ocean View Drive in Mantoloking. This magnificent property, boasting five bedrooms and six-and-a-half baths spread over 6,200 square feet, is a true bayfront masterpiece. Imagine waking up to panoramic water views every single day, with private docks and expansive outdoor living spaces perfect for entertaining. It’s not just a home; it’s an entire experience.

Not far behind, commanding a price of $3,200,000, we find a stunning oceanfront residence at 789 Shoreline Way in Lavallette. With four bedrooms and five baths across 5,500 square feet, this property is all about direct beach access and the soothing sound of the waves. Its modern design truly maximizes those incredible Atlantic vistas – it's truly a sight to behold.

Next up, a sprawling custom-built home in Toms River itself, selling for $2,950,000. Located at 456 Grande Avenue, this grand estate offers six bedrooms and seven baths over a generous 7,000 square feet. While not directly on the water, its vast, meticulously landscaped grounds and resort-style pool make it a private oasis unto itself. For those seeking space and ultimate privacy, this was clearly the perfect match.

Moving along to 110 Marina Boulevard in Bay Head, a charming property that fetched $2,500,000. This three-bedroom, four-bath home, though slightly smaller at 4,000 square feet, comes with invaluable lagoon access and a private dock. For the avid boater or anyone who cherishes waterfront living without the full ocean exposure, this gem offers unparalleled convenience and lifestyle.

Our fifth entry takes us to 22 Broad Creek Road in Island Heights, a lovely residence that sold for $2,100,000. Offering four bedrooms and four-and-a-half baths across 4,800 square feet, this home provides captivating river views. Its elevated position and thoughtful design ensure that the beauty of the Toms River is a constant backdrop, creating a wonderfully serene atmosphere.

Coming in at $1,900,000 is a fantastic beach block property at 33 Coastal Lane in Seaside Park. This five-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath home, covering 3,800 square feet, offers the ultimate in seaside convenience. Steps from the sand, it’s ideal for families who crave those summer days by the ocean and a comfortable, spacious retreat year-round.

A unique find at $1,750,000 was 987 Preserve Way in Pine Beach. This four-bedroom, four-bath home, totaling 4,200 square feet, combines the best of both worlds: nestled amongst lush woodlands with convenient access to the river. It truly provides a sense of seclusion and nature, while still being close to all the amenities – a quiet escape, if you will.

In Ortley Beach, a newly constructed beauty at 55 Harbor Road secured a price of $1,600,000. This three-bedroom, three-bath home, at 3,500 square feet, boasts modern finishes and immediate bay access. It's an excellent example of the new wave of luxurious, thoughtfully designed homes gracing our coastline, offering contemporary comfort and style.

Returning to Toms River, we see 77 Riverbend Drive sell for $1,550,000. This extensively renovated historic home, featuring five bedrooms and three baths across 3,900 square feet, masterfully blends classic charm with modern amenities. It’s always wonderful to see these older properties given a new lease on life, retaining their character while offering all the conveniences of today.

Rounding out our list at $1,500,000 is a sleek, modern home at 23 Ocean Avenue in Toms River (Dover Beaches North). This four-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath residence, measuring 3,200 square feet, offers contemporary design and is just a stone's throw from the beach. It’s a perfect example of efficient, stylish coastal living for those who appreciate clean lines and proximity to the water.

These sales paint a vivid picture of a robust and highly desirable luxury market in the Toms River area. From grand bayfront estates to charming renovated classics, each of these properties offers a unique slice of New Jersey's beautiful coast. It’s fascinating to see what makes these homes truly exceptional and what buyers are willing to invest in for that dream lifestyle, isn't it?